top of page

Trackers vs Immobilisers: Navigating the Maze of Car Security 2024

Vehicle Trackers vs. Vehicle Immobilisers: Navigating the Maze of Car Security

In today's world, car theft remains a persistent threat. Whether you own a classic car or a brand new model, safeguarding your vehicle is crucial. Two popular options in the car security arena are vehicle trackers and vehicle immobilizers. While both aim to deter theft and increase security, they operate in vastly different ways. Choosing the right option depends on your specific needs and priorities. Let's delve into the pros and cons of each technology to help you make an informed decision.

Vehicle Trackers: Trackers vs Immobilisers


  • Recovery, not prevention: Unlike immobilizers, trackers don't physically prevent theft. However, they offer the invaluable benefit of real-time location tracking, allowing authorities to locate your stolen vehicle and potentially recover it. This can lead to quicker recoveries, minimizing damage and inconvenience.

  • Multiple applications: Trackers aren't solely limited to theft recovery. They can be used for monitoring vehicle usage, especially for fleet management or lending purposes. Additionally, some trackers offer geofencing capabilities, which can alert you if your car leaves a designated area without authorization.

  • Wide range of options: Trackers come in a variety of sizes, functionalities, and price points. You can choose from hidden hardwired trackers to portable magnetic trackers, allowing for customization based on your budget and desired level of discretion.

Cons: Trackers vs Immobilisers

  • Subscription costs: Most trackers require a monthly subscription fee for cellular connectivity and access to tracking services. These recurring costs can add up over time.

  • Limited effectiveness against professional theft: While helpful for recovery, trackers don't actively prevent theft. Skilled thieves might be able to disable trackers before escaping the scene.

  • Privacy concerns: Real-time location tracking raises privacy concerns for some individuals. Ensure you understand the data collection and usage policies before choosing a tracker.

Vehicle Immobilisers: (THE CAN PHANTOM) Trackers vs Immobilisers


  • Active theft prevention: Immobilizers act as a deterrent, making it difficult or impossible to start the vehicle without a specific code or key fob. This significantly reduces the chances of successful theft, offering peace of mind for car owners.

  • Cost-effective: Immobilizers often have a one-time installation cost and don't require ongoing subscriptions like trackers. This can be a more budget-friendly option compared to subscription-based trackers.

  • Variety of options: Similar to trackers, immobilizers come in various types with different functionalities. You can choose from standalone systems or opt for integrated solutions that work in conjunction with your car's existing alarm system.

  • Potential insurance discounts: Some insurance companies offer discounts for vehicles equipped with our CAN PHANTOM immobiliser, as they increase the chances of theft and reduce the overall risk for the insurer.


  • Limited functionality: Immobilizers solely focus on theft prevention and don't offer additional features like tracking or location monitoring.

Choosing the Right Option: Trackers vs Immobilisers

The best choice between a vehicle tracker and an immobilizer depends on your priorities:

  • Prioritize prevention: If actively deterring theft is paramount, an immobilizer is a strong choice.

  • Consider The CAN PHANTOM Immobiliser: For comprehensive security,  it offers the best options.  In a case like vehicle theft, prevention is always better than recovery.

Trackers vs Immobilisers

115 views0 comments


bottom of page